Wall Street loves stock repurchases. In the fourth quarter of 2019, companies on the S&P 500 spent an estimated $189 billion buying back their shares from the stock market. It was the highest in three quarters but not the highest on record. In the final quarter of 2018, that number was about $223 billion, a high point on a decade-long trend. So have stock buyback rules changed recently? Let’s find out.
Table of Contents
- 5 Second Takeaway: Stock Buyback Rules
- Are Buybacks Good For The Economy?
- Stock Buyback Rules To Know
5 Second Takeaway: Stock Buyback Rules
- Reduces the number of shares outstanding.
- Earnings-per-share go up
- Stock value goes up
- Earnings are “diluted” when the number of shares outstanding increases, reducing per-share earnings.
- Share buybacks have become a significant component of public issuers’ return capital to shareholders.
Since 2010, companies on the S&P have poured more than $5.3 trillion into repurchasing their shares. Analysts say buybacks have been a driving force in the decade-long bull market.
But there’s some argument about whether they’re good for the economy. To understand the debate, you have to understand how stock buybacks work. And what the stock buyback rules are.
What Is A Stock Buyback?
The principle of stock buyback rules is simple. On the one hand, companies can obtain additional capital by issuing shares and letting others “own” a piece of the company.
On the other hand, they can also do the exact opposite by “buying out” existing shareholders.
Company ownership is Diluted when issuing shares and consolidated when buying them back.
For many reasons. Hence why stock buyback rules exist.
They, firstly, have excess liquidity and no better alternative concerning using it.
Secondly, considering the shares undervalued. For example, if you buy back 1000 shares at $10 each and issue 1000 shares when the price reaches 20 bucks, you essentially make money without ownership dilution.
Making The Numbers Look Good
Thirdly, making certain metrics look more attractive. For example, your earnings per share or EPS will be higher if you have fewer shares.
An Alternative To Dividends
Four, for implementing an alternative to dividends or making shareholders happy through asset appreciation rather than handing them money directly. Tweaking buyback approaches based on market conditions arguably involves fewer headaches. The main idea is that the market, for example, responds less aggressively to share buybacks instead of lower dividends.
Five questionable reasons, such as a bunch of decision-makers who own stocks themselves initiating a buyback. Which, conveniently for them, makes share prices go up. In other words, they are buying back shares because it’s in their best interest than that of the business.
Are Buybacks Good For The Economy?
Skeptics say the money used on stock buybacks would be better spent elsewhere, like building new factories or exploring new opportunities altogether. Meanwhile, for proponents, buybacks put money right where it belongs: With shareholders.
Harvey J. Goldschmid, former general counsel at the SEC, firmly believed that stock repurchases made by company managers with the material inside information can disturb “the integrity of the markets.” With stock buyback rules, that does allow some protection.
Disturbing The Integrity of The Market
“The integrity of the markets is disturbed if insiders, including managers in a company, purchase shares based on material information,” says Harvey J. Goldschmid, general counsel of the SEC in Washington, D.C.
That applies whether the insider purchases stock for his or the company’s account.
Think of a situation where a company knows shares soon would double in value due to a discovery—without telling shareholders about the discovery. That creates a kind of unfairness that is fraudulent.
You know this as insider trading. And you likely know someone guilty of it who spent jail time: Martha Stewart. So even though the scenario was the opposite, it’s still action based on insider information.
What Is Insider Trading?
Insider trading refers to buying or selling a publicly-traded company’s securities while possessing knowledge the public does not have.
By non-public information, I mean that the information is not legally out in the public domain—basically, only a small handful of people directly related to the information possessed.
An example of an insider may be a corporate executive or someone in government who has access to an economic report before it is publicly released.
Take, for example, Martha Stewart. Stewart committed illegal insider trading in 2001 when she sold stock in a biopharmaceutical company after receiving an unlawful tip. As a result, she dumped Stewart all of her 3928 securities.
Shortly after, ImClone stock fell by 60% due to the rejection of the company’s application for a key cancer drug.
Stock Buyback Rules To Know
Buying back shares, as counterintuitive as it may seem, makes perfect sense sometimes. However, things can get taken too far, as in the scenario above. There are extensive regulations governing corporate share repurchases.
Follow Rule 10b-18
Rewind to 1934, section 12 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, Rule 10b-18—Purchases of Certain Equity Securities by the Issuer and Others Act. The rule is designed so the company can’t make multiple trades through multiple brokers and try to pump up the stock’s price.
Just in December last year, the SEC proposed changes to rule 10b-18. The proposed amendments would require an issuer to disclose several things:
- the objective or rationale for the share repurchases
- the process or criteria used to determine the repurchase amounts
The proposed rules would require an issuer to provide a new Form SR before the end of the first business day after the issuer executes a share repurchase.
Form SR would require disclosure identifying the class of securities purchased, the total amount purchased, and the average price paid, as well as the aggregate total amount purchased on the open market in reliance on the safe harbor in Exchange Act Rule 10b-18 or under a plan that is intended to satisfy the affirmative defense conditions of Exchange Act Rule 10b5-1(c). The SEC’s end goal is to ensure transparency for all.
Timing Of The Stock Buyback
Even if a board of directors authorizes the immediate launch of a buyback program, it doesn’t happen immediately. And in many instances, the CFO will delay the buyback to ensure they follow the law.
Staying Out of Jail By Having a “Black Out” Period
Many companies give their broker a heads-up to address the risk of insider trading. In other words, they let them know trading may need to be suspended. In addition, many companies apply a “blackout period .”
During this time, all trades—to corporate repurchases are forbidden. This is the same as they do for insider stock purchases by individuals. In many cases, a company may decide not to trade during a period that extends from 10 days before through two days after an earnings release.
The bottom line is that these share repurchases, stock buybacks, share buybacks, or whatever we call them, are tools. They are not inherently good or evil; it all depends on how they’re used. But it’s important to know the stock buyback rules.